• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Dirt Diva Diaries logo with roots at the bottom of the letters and flowers/leaves coming out the top

Dirt Diva Diaries

Grow Your Own Way

  • How To Guides
    • Herbs
    • Fruits
    • Vegetables
    • Supplies and Technical Guides
  • Resources
    • Gardening Terms
    • Plant Index
    • Products
    • Our Books
  • Ivy’s Diary
  • Get My Free Stuff!
  • Show Search
Hide Search
homegrown, vibrant tomatoes grown with natural tomato fertilizers

Natural Tomato Fertilizers: Feed Your Future Slices!

Say Goodbye to Chemical Chaos!

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, meaning we get a commission if you decide to make a purchase through our links, at no cost to you. See our full disclosure here.

Alright, listen up, my budding botanical buddies! You’ve got the dirt under your fingernails, the sunshine on your face, and a hankerin’ for some of that sweet, sweet taste of homegrown goodness. And what says summer garden glory more than a big, juicy, red tomato? Exactly! But let’s be real. Sometimes our soil needs a little pep in its step to deliver those brag-worthy fruits. That’s where the magic of natural tomato fertilizers comes in, and trust me, it’s way less scary than it sounds.

Forget those complicated charts and chemical concoctions that make you feel like you need a PhD just to feed your plants. Here at DirtDivaDiaries.com, we’re all about keepin’ it real, keepin’ it fun, and most importantly, gettin’ those tomatoes plump and perfect the way Mother Nature intended–with a little nudge from some fantastic natural tomato fertilizers.

5 tomatoes at varying stages of ripeness on the vine

Why go natural, you ask? Well, for starters, you’re feeding your plants the good stuff–the kind of nourishment that builds strong roots, vibrant leaves, and flavor that’ll knock your socks off. Plus, you’re being kind to the earth, and that’s always a good look, wouldn’t you agree? We’re talkin’ about creating a happy ecosystem in your backyard, where your tomatoes thrive and the planet breathes a little easier.

Now, I know what some of you might be thinkin’. “Natural? Does that even work?” Oh, honey, it doesn’t just work, it works wonders! We’re gonna ditch the mystery ingredients and dive into some tried-and-true natural fertilizers for your tomatoes that are readily available and easy to use. Think of it as giving your tomato plants a delicious and nutritious meal, the kind that makes them say, “More, please!”

So, buckle up, buttercups! We’re about to embark on a journey through the wonderful world of natural tomato fertilizers. We’ll explore some of the top players in the game, break down what makes them so darn good, and give you the lowdown on how to use them to achieve tomato nirvana. Get ready to grow your own way to the most flavorful harvest you’ve ever imagined!

Espoma Tomato-Tone: The Organic All-Star

Alright, let’s get down and dirty with our first superstar in the lineup of natural tomato fertilizers: Espoma Tomato-Tone! Now, if you’ve dipped even a toe into the organic gardening world, you’ve probably heard whispers about this one. It’s like the reliable best friend of the tomato patch–always there to lend a helping hand and get the job done right.

Espoma Organic Tomato-Tone 3-4-6 with 8% Calcium. Organic Fertili...

Espoma Organic Tomato-Tone 3-4-6 with 8% Calcium. Organic Fertili…

$24.21
Buy on Amazon

Espoma Tomato-Tone isn’t some fly-by-night fancy product; it’s a well-established, organic fertilizer specifically formulated for our beloved tomatoes (and peppers and eggplants, but we’re all about the red orbs today!). What makes it so darn dependable? Well, it’s all about that slow-release magic. Think of it as a time-release vitamin for your plants. Instead of a sudden jolt of nutrients that can sometimes be too much for tender roots, Tomato-Tone gradually feeds your plants over several weeks. This consistent nourishment leads to steady growth, strong root systems that can really anchor those heavy tomato-laden branches, and a beautiful bounty of fruit.

Now, let’s peek under the hood and see what makes this natural tomato fertilizer tick. The NPK ratio you’ll usually find for Tomato-Tone is around 3-4-6. Now, for you newbie dirt divas and dudes, NPK stands for Nitrogen (N), Phosphorus (P), and Potassium (K)–the three main macronutrients that plants need. Nitrogen is all about leafy growth, phosphorus is crucial for root development and flowering (hello, future tomatoes!), and potassium helps with overall plant health and fruit production. That 3-4-6 balance is pretty spot-on for what tomatoes crave, especially as they start to set fruit.

infographic showing what NPK is, it's role in natural tomato fertilizers, and why it matters to tomato plants

But it’s not just about the numbers, it’s about what makes up those numbers! Espoma Tomato-Tone boasts a fantastic blend of natural and organic ingredients:

  • Composted poultry manure: Don’t wrinkle your nose! This isn’t just any old chicken poop. It’s been properly composted, meaning it’s broken down into a nutrient-rich, earthy goodness that your plants will adore. It’s a significant source of all three NPK players, plus it introduces beneficial microbes into your soil. These little guys are like tiny helpers that break down organic matter and make nutrients more available to your plants. It’s a win-win!
  • Bone meal: Ah, bone meal–the secret weapon for root development and flower power! This is exactly what it sounds like: ground-up animal bones. Now, before you get all squeamish, know that this is a fantastic source of phosphorus, which, as we discussed, is vital for those blossoms that eventually turn into juicy tomatoes. It’s a slow-release source, ensuring your plants get a steady supply.
  • Alfalfa meal: This might sound like something you feed horses, but trust me, your tomatoes will thank you for it! Alfalfa meal is packed with trace minerals and micronutrients that are essential for overall plant health. Think of it as a multivitamin for your green babies. Plus, as it breaks down in the soil, it improves the soil structure, making it easier for roots to grow and breathe.

So, how do you actually use this magic potion? It’s pretty straightforward. When you’re planting your tomato seedlings, dig your hole and then sprinkle some Tomato-Tone into the bottom of the hole and mix it in with the soil. This gives those little roots a nutrient boost right from the start. As your plants grow, you can also “side-dress” them. This just means gently working some more Tomato-Tone into the soil near the base of the plant, being careful not to disturb the roots. Follow the instructions on the bag for the correct amounts based on the size of your plants.

A little tip from your favorite sassy gardener: Don’t just sprinkle it and run, darlings! Gently work that Tomato-Tone into the top inch or two of the soil and then water it in well. This helps those nutrients start their journey down to the roots where they’re needed most. Think of it as tucking your plants into bed with a nutritious snack!

Espoma Tomato-Tone is a fantastic choice for newbie gardeners because it’s gentle, it’s organic, and it takes the guesswork out of feeding your tomatoes. It’s like giving your plants a balanced and delicious meal without having to be a soil science whiz. So, if you’re looking for a reliable and natural tomato fertilizer to get you started on your tomato-growing adventure, Tomato-Tone is definitely a winner!

Down To Earth Organic All Purpose Fertilizer: The Versatile Virtuoso

Alright, my verdant virtuosos, let’s move on to our next contender in the realm of natural tomato fertilizers: the Down To Earth Organic All Purpose Fertilizer! Now, don’t let the “all purpose” part fool ya. While it’s a fantastic workhorse for a variety of plants, it’s got some serious chops when it comes to gettin’ those tomatoes to thrive. Think of it as the multi-talented musician in our fertilizer band–plays a lot of instruments, and plays them well!

Down To Earth All Natural Fertilizers Organic All Purpose Tomato ...

Down To Earth All Natural Fertilizers Organic All Purpose Tomato …

  • Down To Earth All Purpose Mix is a five pound box of fertilizer with 4-6-2 formula and is ideal for all types of transpl…
  • A gentle, non-burning fertilizer made for vegetables, herbs, flowers and container plants, it is formulated with premium…
  • Designed to deliver a steady supply of essential nutrients to your plants while enhancing soil fertility and microbial a…
$18.99
Buy on Amazon

Down To Earth offers a range of organic fertilizers, but their “All Purpose” blend is a popular choice for us dirt divas and dudes who like a bit of versatility. It’s a mix of natural and organic ingredients that work together to feed your plants gently and effectively. You’ll typically find this blend sporting an NPK ratio of around 4-4-4. Notice how it’s a bit more balanced across the board compared to the Tomato-Tone? This makes it a great foundational fertilizer, providing a good mix of nutrients for overall plant health, from root to fruit.

So, what’s in this magical mix? Let’s dig in:

  • Fish bone meal: Ah, our old friend bone meal is back for an encore, but this time with a fishy twist! Fish bone meal is another excellent source of that all-important phosphorus, promoting strong root development and abundant flowering. Plus, some folks swear it adds a little extra oomph to the flavor of your fruits (though that might just be garden lore!).
  • Kelp meal: Get ready for a dose of sea-based goodness! Kelp meal is derived from dried seaweed and is an absolute treasure trove of trace elements and micronutrients. Think of it as a spa day for your plants, providing them with all sorts of goodies they might be missing. It also contains natural growth hormones that can give your tomatoes an extra boost.
  • Alfalfa meal: Our alfalfa friend is back in the mix! Just like in the Tomato-Tone, it provides valuable trace minerals and helps improve that precious soil structure. It’s like the reliable backup singer, always there to harmonize and make everything better.
  • Other potential players: Depending on the specific Down To Earth “All Purpose” blend, you might also find ingredients like feather meal (a source of nitrogen) or rock phosphate (another slow-release source of phosphorus). Don’t let these fancy names intimidate you! Just know they’re all-natural goodies working to feed your plants.

Now, how do you get this versatile virtuoso to work its magic on your tomatoes? Just like with the Tomato-Tone, you’ll want to work it into the soil when you’re planting your seedlings. Sprinkle some into the planting hole and mix it in. As your plants grow and start setting fruit, you can also side dress with the Down To Earth fertilizer. Gently work it into the soil around the plant and water it in. Always follow the instructions on the bag for the recommended application rates based on your plant size.

Here’s a little sassy tip for you: Because this is an “all purpose” blend, it’s a great option if you’re also growing other veggies or herbs nearby. You can use the same fertilizer for your whole gang, making things a little simpler. Just remember that while it’s versatile, if your tomatoes are really heavy fruit producers, they might appreciate a little extra phosphorus boost later in the season–but we’ll get to that!

Down To Earth Organic All Purpose Fertilizer is a solid choice for the newbie and the seasoned gardener alike. It’s a reliable, natural way to provide your tomato plants with a balanced diet, setting them up for healthy growth and a delicious harvest. It’s like having a dependable friend in the garden, always ready to lend a hand (or a nutrient!).

Great Big Tomatoes Natural Amendment: The Fruit Fanatic

Alright, buckle up buttercups, because we’re about to talk about a natural tomato amendment that’s laser-focused on one thing and one thing only: gettin’ you Great Big Tomatoes! If you’re dreamin’ of those hefty, juicy slicers that make your neighbors green with envy, then this contender deserves a serious look. Think of it as the specialist in our tomato amendment lineup–it knows exactly how to pump up those fruits!

Great Big Tomatoes Natural Fertilizer is formulated with a specific goal in mind: maximizing fruit production and size. I call this product more of an amendment as opposed to a fertilizer. It’s basically a compost tea and full of great stuff for your maters. It is like a multivitamin for your plants. Think of it as the recipe for big, beautiful, and delicious tomatoes!

Great Big Tomatoes – Soil and Tomato Fertilizer Booster to Grow T...

Great Big Tomatoes – Soil and Tomato Fertilizer Booster to Grow T…

  • GREAT FOR BEGINNERS: The quality of garden soil makes a big difference in your garden success, whether it’s in container…
  • GROW YOUR OWN VINE RIPENED TOMATOES: The best tasting tomatoes are vine ripened to maximize flavor and density. When you…
  • IMPROVES FERTILIZER UPTAKE: Our compost extract boosts the effects of fertilizer for tomatoes and tomato plant soils. Th…
$26.50
Buy on Amazon

So, what’s the secret sauce in this fruit-focused formula? Let’s take a peek at some of the key ingredients you might find:

  • Potassium sulfate: This is a readily available source of potassium, the unsung hero of fruit production. It helps with water regulation in the plant, disease resistance, and is key to developing those big, flavorful tomatoes you’re after. Think of it as the muscle builder for your fruits!
  • Rock phosphate: Just like bone meal, rock phosphate is a natural source of phosphorus. However, it tends to release its nutrients a bit more slowly, providing a long-term supply for your hungry tomato plants. It’s like the slow and steady fuel source for continuous blooming and fruiting.
  • Humic acids: These naturally occurring organic compounds are like soil conditioners on steroids! They help improve nutrient uptake by making it easier for the plant’s roots to absorb the good stuff from the fertilizer. They also help improve soil structure and water retention. Think of them as the facilitators, making sure your plants get the most bang for their fertilizer buck.
  • Beneficial microbes: Just like in our other natural fertilizers, Great Big Tomatoes often includes a blend of beneficial bacteria and fungi. These little guys work wonders in the soil, breaking down organic matter, making nutrients more available, and even helping to protect your plants from certain diseases. They’re the tiny superheroes of the soil food web!

Now, how do you unleash the big tomato potential with this fertilizer? Typically, you’ll want to incorporate it into the soil at planting time, making sure those young roots have access to the phosphorus they need for strong development. Basically, just follow the directions. You are going to mix it in your water and feed your plants regularly. This product is one of those that can push your harvests from normal to insane.

Here’s a little sassy secret for you big tomato dreamers: Consistent watering is key when you’re aiming for those massive fruits. All the fertilizer in the world won’t help if your plants are thirsty! So, keep that soil consistently moist, especially when those tomatoes are sizing up.

Great Big Tomatoes Natural Fertilizer is your go-to if your primary goal is, well, great big tomatoes! It’s specifically formulated to support heavy fruiting and size, giving you the best chance at those prize-winning specimens. So, if you’re ready to grow some tomatoes that’ll make your neighbors do a double-take, this might just be your new best friend in the garden!

How to Choose the Right Natural Tomato Fertilizer for YOU (Grow Your Own Way!)

Alright, my discerning dirt devotees, we’ve looked at some fantastic contenders in the world of natural tomato fertilizers. But with all these glorious options, how do you pick the right one for your precious patch? Don’t fret, my dears, we’re gonna break it down so you can grow your own way to tomato success!

a basket of tomatoes next to a gardening hat and onions
Homegrown juicy tomatoes

The truth is, there’s no single “best” natural tomato fertilizer out there. It really boils down to a few key factors unique to your garden and your gardening style. Think of it like dating–what works for your bestie might not be your cup of tea (or should I say, your soil’s delight!).

Here’s what you need to ponder:

  • Your Soil’s Story: Have you ever had your soil tested? If not, it might be worth considering, especially if you’ve struggled with plant growth in the past. A soil test will tell you exactly what nutrients your soil is lacking (or has too much of!). This knowledge can help you choose a natural tomato fertilizer that targets those specific needs. If your soil is already pretty balanced, a good all-around option like Down To Earth might be just the ticket.
  • Your Budget, Buttercup: Let’s be real, gardening can sometimes feel like a money pit (albeit a beautiful and delicious one!). Natural tomato fertilizers come in a range of price points. Consider how much you’re willing to invest. Espoma Tomato-Tone and Down To Earth are generally readily available and won’t break the bank. If you’re serious about those giant tomatoes, you might be willing to splurge a bit more on something like Great Big Tomatoes.
  • Slow and Steady or a Little Boost? Think about your gardening style: Do you prefer the ease of a slow-release fertilizer like Espoma Tomato-Tone that feeds your plants consistently over time? Or are you the type who likes to keep a closer eye on things and perhaps supplement with other natural amendments later in the season? Down To Earth offers a good balance, while something like a liquid fish emulsion (not one of our main contenders today, but worth a mention!) can provide a quicker boost.
  • Ingredient Intimacy: Take a peek at those ingredient lists! Are there any particular natural ingredients you feel strongly about using (or avoiding)? Maybe you’re all about the bone meal for that phosphorus punch, or perhaps you’re intrigued by the kelp meal’s trace mineral magic. Get to know what you’re feeding your plants!
  • Your Tomato Dreams: What are your ultimate tomato goals? Are you aiming for a massive harvest of all sizes? Or are you specifically chasing those brag-worthy, dinner-plate-sized beauties? If it’s the latter, then a fertilizer like Great Big Tomatoes, specifically formulated for fruit production, might give you an edge.

Ultimately, my green-thumbed friends, the best way to choose is often a little bit of experimentation. Don’t be afraid to try one natural tomato fertilizer this season and see how your plants respond. You might find a favorite that becomes your go-to, or you might even decide to try different ones on different plants to see what works best in your unique Yakima garden.

What do I do? Well, I like both Down To Earth and Espoma and I intermix the two. I think every fertilizer has a slightly different ratio of ingredients, so using more than one can be a good thing. However, for the sake of ease, I would just buy whichever one is on sale if you are only buying one. Then, I also use Great Big Tomatoes since it is more of a compost tea than a fertilizer. The combination of a fertilizer and Great Big Tomatoes will produce healthy, highly productive plants. 

Remember our motto here at DirtDivaDiaries.com: grow your own way! Gardening isn’t about rigid rules; it’s about connecting with nature and finding what works best for you and your green babies. So, trust your gut (and maybe a little bit of research!), and get ready to feed those future slices!

Feeding Frenzy: Tips for Fertilizing Like a Pro (Without the Fuss)

Alright, my diligent dirt diggers, you’ve chosen your weapon in the battle for beautiful tomatoes! Now, let’s talk tactics–how to actually get that natural tomato fertilizer working its magic without making a mess or overdoing it. Trust me, feeding your plants should be a nurturing ritual, not a chaotic free-for-all!

Here are a few golden rules to keep in mind when you’re treating your tomatoes to a nutrient-rich feast:

  • Keep it Simple, Sweetheart: Don’t overthink this! Most natural tomato fertilizers come with clear instructions on the bag or container. Read them! I know, I know, reading instructions isn’t always the most glamorous part of gardening, but it’s crucial for knowing how much to use and how often. They’ll usually give you guidelines based on the size of your plants and whether you’re planting or already growing.
  • Water Wisely After the Feast: Once you’ve applied your chosen natural tomato fertilizer, give your plants a good drink of water. This helps to dissolve the nutrients and move them down into the soil where those eager roots can soak them up. Think of it as serving a refreshing beverage with a delicious meal!
  • Observe and Learn, My Lovelies: Your plants are great communicators–you just gotta learn their language! Keep an eye on their leaves. Are they a vibrant green? Are they growing steadily? Are they producing flowers and setting fruit? These are all signs of a happy, well-fed tomato plant. If you see yellowing leaves or stunted growth, it could be a sign of nutrient deficiency (or something else!), so do a little investigating. But generally, if they look good, you’re on the right track!
  • Easy Does It, Don’t Overdo It! More isn’t always better when it comes to fertilizer, even the natural kind. Over-fertilizing can actually harm your plants, leading to leggy growth, weak stems, and even nutrient burn. Stick to the recommended rates on the product label. Your tomatoes will be grateful for the balanced diet, not a buffet of excess!
  • Timing is Everything (Almost!): Generally, you’ll want to fertilize your tomato plants at planting time to give them a good start. Then, as they grow, you can apply more fertilizer as a side dressing every few weeks. This provides them with the extra nutrients they need during this energy-intensive phase. Again, those product instructions are your best friend here!

Listen, feeding your tomato plants with natural tomato fertilizers shouldn’t feel like a chore. It’s an act of nurturing, a way to give your green babies the building blocks they need to produce those delicious fruits you’ve been dreaming of. So, take a deep breath, follow these simple tips, and enjoy the process. You’ve got this, my fantastic fruit fanatics!

Conclusion: Natural Tomato Fertilizers for Happy Tomatoes and Happy Gardeners!

Alright, my fabulous fruit fiends, we’ve reached the grand finale of our deep dive! You’ve learned about some rockstar organic options, figured out how to choose the best one for your dirt, and even got the lowdown on how to feed your future slices like a pro (without the fuss!). With all this knowledge, you can pick the natural tomato fertilizer that is best for you and your garden!

Espoma Organic Tomato-Tone 3-4-6 with 8% Calcium. Organic Fertili...

Espoma Organic Tomato-Tone 3-4-6 with 8% Calcium. Organic Fertili…

$24.21
Buy on Amazon
Down To Earth All Natural Fertilizers Organic All Purpose Tomato ...

Down To Earth All Natural Fertilizers Organic All Purpose Tomato …

$18.99
Buy on Amazon
Great Big Tomatoes – Soil and Tomato Fertilizer Booster to Grow T...

Great Big Tomatoes – Soil and Tomato Fertilizer Booster to Grow T…

$26.50
Buy on Amazon

Now, the only thing left to do is get out there and get growing! Remember, gardening isn’t about following some dusty old rulebook. It’s about connecting with the earth, nurturing life, and enjoying the journey–from those tiny little seedlings to the moment you pluck that first sun-warmed, juicy tomato.

Using natural tomato fertilizers is just one way to show your plants a little love and set them up for success. You’re not just feeding them nutrients; you’re building healthy soil, supporting beneficial microbes, and creating a vibrant ecosystem right in your own backyard. And the best part? You’re doing it all without those scary chemicals, knowing you’re growing food that’s good for you and good for the planet.

So, take the plunge, my daring dirt divas and dudes! Don’t be afraid to experiment, to get your hands dirty, and to learn what works best in your own little corner of the world. Whether you choose the steady goodness of Espoma Tomato-Tone, the versatile power of Down To Earth, or the fruit-focused might of Great Big Tomatoes, you’re one step closer to a harvest that will make your taste buds sing.

And remember, here at DirtDivaDiaries.com, it’s about celebrating the journey and cheering on every single green thumb. So, go forth, feed those future slices with confidence, and grow your own way to a season of delicious success! Now, if you’ll excuse me, I’ve got some tomatoes that need a little Ivy love!

Primary Sidebar

I want FREE stuff

I want personalized freebies to help me on my gardening journey!


Search our site

Recent Adventures

someone using horticultural oil spray to protect their garden

Horticultural Oil Spray: Your Go-To for Healthy, Happy Plants

Horticultural oil is a time-tested and environmentally conscious solution for managing various pests …

Continue Reading about Horticultural Oil Spray: Your Go-To for Healthy, Happy Plants

Explore more

Newsletter Sign Up For a Free Gardening Book

Dirt Diva Diaries in a custom logo font with flowers and roots coming out of the letters

Footer

Dirt Diva Diaries

Grow Your Own Way

Copyright © 2025 · All Rights Reserved · Dirt Diva Diaries

Check Us Out on Social Media

InstagramFacebookPinterestThreads
  • About Dirt Diva Diaries
  • Get My Free Stuff!
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Affiliate & Health Disclosures
  • Opt-out preferences
Manage Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}